Let's for a moment recount Majrooh Sultanpuri's famous lines from the 1956 cult classic, C.I.D :
Kahin pe nigaahein, kahin pe nishaana
Jeene do zaalim, banao na deewana
Now let's come back to the present. The new Uttarakhand CM (I remind you, he's very very very new : the last CM was replaced just a couple of weeks back ) says that it was Amrika that ruled over us for 200 years, and that the Sun never set on that empire, bla bla bla ... Are we really supposed to believe that any person in India, whose profession is politics, doesn't know about the British? Or is it by design that this guy keeps making controversial statements every week, be it on women's attire, or on our overlords?
His appointment has served its purpose. He has been given a particular job and he has proven to be quite good at it. He is the bait where someone wants our nigaahein to rest on, and my friend, the nishaana are you and me.
Koi na jaane, irade hain kidhar ke
If you thought that that was the only game being played last week, you are
mistaken. Pratap Bhanu Mehta's resignation, followed by Arvind
Subramanian's, is the other tip of a very deep iceberg. Destroying the
only good Indian private (and liberal) university's reputation plays right
into the hands of the powers that be.
Maar na de na teer nazar ka kisike jigar pe
Naazuk yeh dil hai, bachana o bachana.
In West Bengal, all of a sudden one sees chaos in the BJP ranks due
to quite a few 'unsatisfactory' candidatures. It is as if the BJP got
cold feet because the wind was indeed favorable, and that the party WANTS to
lose this election to TMC. The Bengal assembly in any case is all set to have a strong opposition for the first time in more than 50 years. Is it really though a bipolar election? If the CPIM-INC coalition is indeed serious about banking on anti-incumbency, where is the fight on the ground? One would expect that they must be seriously concerned about the BJP eating into their vote share. Memes do not win you elections, issues do. Does the Bengali voter know what she is voting for? Is corruption the agenda? Or is it unemployment? Is she voting to assert her religious identity? Or is the concern cultural pride? The state votes in a few weeks, and we do not have a single clear message from any political party. The media has built up a local election at the national scale, and none of the TMC spokespersons has shown the maturity to lower the stakes! It's only appalling. If a wheelchair dominates headlines, it simply tells a story of the state's spine.
While I made an abrupt jump from national to state politics, to my eyes there is a distinct similarity. It is as if no matter whether it's the incumbent or the challenger, a game of distractions is all that is going on. I quote Majrooh Sahab once again :
Tauba ji tauba, nigaahon ka machalna
Dekhbhal ke ae dilwalo pehlu badalna
Kaafir ada ki ada hain mastana
Tagore argued long back in his Nationalism leaflet about the pyramidal structure of power in India where the base and the body remain static, and the tip keeps flirting with various changes. One would expect that to have changed during 70 years of democracy, but alas! West Bengal, literally and metaphorically is still stuck in the past, in the worst possible way. If this goes on, the Bengali children will keep losing their childhood to the same old illusions, and the parents will keep spending the dusk alone, but with inflated egos, thanks to their successful children paying taxes in distant countries. But election after election, we will not ask questions about the detrimental re-distributive policies of the Left, or of the Congress breaking the backbone of the youth in the 1970s. Neither shall we ask why there is such brazen corruption at every level today, nor do we feel the need to question why "Jay Shree Ram" is relevant at all! We will leave ourselves at the mercy of the political goons, and sing :
Kar do ji ghayal, tumhara hai zaamana!
In our democracy even NOTA does not make practical sense. The only hope then, is in the people, strangely, where it should be. Unless the people start asking questions, the political banners won't. But indeed, are we, the people, really deserving of good governance in West Bengal?
In a state where intellectuals look down upon anything beyond Dumdum and Garia, at least yours truly doesn't expect change anytime soon. We hear a lot about the Bengali pride. But whom are we kidding? Bengal's history is as colonized as it could be. Anything and everything rests with Kolkata, and so does the Bengali pride, that is being marketed nowadays. If you are a Bengali from Kolkata, and you know who you are, ask yourself how much of an oriental attitude you suffer from. You speak, in the same breath, of Cuba, Moscow, Vietnam, but you haven't heard of Patiram. You mock the knowledge of idiotic anchors when they say that Tagore was born in Santiniketan, but you mock the dialect of the very people of Bolpur if you get a chance. You say that caste is irrelevant in West Bengal because you have only seen Kolkata, a city dominated by the upper castes. Give me one Bengal chief minister from the so-called "lower" castes.
To be honest, the hypocritical Kolkata-elite is in decay. It's a process that has just started. Don't make the mistake of thinking that only people born in Kolkata make up this elite. It is a self-feeding structure. It has contributions from every district of Bengal. This elitism is a seductress, and the honey-trap is laid for everyone - man, woman, transgender, Brahmin, Kayastha, Shudra, Dalit, Muslim, you name it. The seduction of being hailed as an intellectual Kolkata-Bengali is the disease that has become a terminal illness.
Aaya shikari, o panchhi tu sambhal ja
Dekh jaal hain zulfo ka, tu chupke se nikal ja.
Like in any other illness, the vogue-word is "roots". Until each of us
accepts our respective roots, there can never be any Bengali pride. This means an outright rejection of trying to fit-in anymore. It
is only then that we will truly ask relevant questions to and of the power
structure.
Till we meet again, let me leave you with Sahir's memorable lines from the Guru Dutt-debut Baazi :
"Tadbeer se bigdi hui taqdeer bana le,
Aapne pe bharosa hain to yeh daav laga le"